Blight, David W.
Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory
Belknap of Harvard (Cambridge)
2001
OUR SYNOPSIS: David W. Blight chronicles “how Americans remembered their most divisive and tragic experience during the fifty-year period after the Civil War.” (1) He identifies three key versions of Civil War memory that clash and overlap: reconciliationist, white supremacist, and emancipationist. Emphasizing the success of the first version, he argues that “The sectional reunion after so horrible a civil war was a political triumph by the late nineteenth century, but it could not have been achieved without the resubjugation of many of those people whom the war had freed from centuries of bondage.” (2-3) Despite this reconciliationist triumph, he emphasizes that Black Americans persisted in remembering and embodying their own version of the war as an ongoing liberation struggle. However, romanticized white memory blocked genuine national collective healing during and after Reconstruction. He shows that Decoration Day, later renamed Memorial Day, became a key pillar of the national reunion narrative. Meanwhile, white supremacists implemented a regime of racial violence in attempts to prevent Black southerners from exercising rights of citizenship.
BIG QUESTIONS:
To what extent did Americans resist, or not, the reconciliationist narrative?
What role has Abraham Lincoln played as a historical figure in the building of Civil War memory?
What role did northerners and other Union loyalists play in the triumph of the reconciliationist narrative and failure of genuine national collective healing?
FEATURE QUOTES:
“During Reconstruction, many Americans increasingly realized that remembering the war, even the hatreds and deaths on a hundred battlefields—facing all those graves on Memorial Day—became, with time, easier than struggling over the enduring ideas for which those battles had been fought.” (31)
“Raw memory pushed against the uncertain future, retribution collided with grudging admiration, vows to never forget and the sounds of rebuilding vied to be heard all at once. The forces of race and reunion were shaping one another even before Reconstruction policies were implemented.” (37)
PRIMARY SOURCES:
Frederick Douglass, “The Color Question,” speech delivered July 5, 1875, Frederick Douglass Papers, Library of Congress, http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.mss/ms000009.mss11879.00415.
BALTIMORE CONNECTIONS:
N/A