top of page

Manning, Chandra

Troubled Refuge: Struggling for Freedom in the Civil War

Vintage (New York)

2016



OUR SYNOPSIS: Chandra Manning explores how Black people fled to the Union army to escape slavery during the Civil War, raising the question of what can be learned from studying these experiences. She first focuses specifically on Union contraband camps that housed enslaved people fleeing slavery, to piece together how “The experience of emancipation began in the intimate details of the everyday.” (28) Most of these fugitive people were women and children. Then she steps back to analyze the more macro-level developments, particularly processes of military emancipation and the pursuit of citizenship. What people fleeing slavery were able to leverage was their great usefulness to the Union in the war effort. In return, they received “not the unearnable gift of freedom, but rather a new, direct relationship with the U.S. government.” (215) Throughout the book, she emphasizes the persistent threat of possible re-enslavement to show the precarity of emancipation. Widespread assumptions about slavery and its relationship to both federal power and Blackness threatened to re-enslave people. This is a big part of why refuge in contraband camps was so troubled, hence the book’s title.

BIG QUESTIONS:

  • What can learn about motivations of enslaved people who fled slavery during the Civil War?

  • How did Black women and children in the South who fled to the Union army experience the upheaval of the Civil War?

FEATURE QUOTES:

  • “Within Union lines, the women and children could see tracks leading out of slavery. Where those tracks led to was far less clear.” (3-4)

  • “This book means citizenship in the way that refugees from slavery meant it as they sought freedom during the Civil War: as a mutually beneficial alliance with the national government that could help both the Union and the freedpeople achieve specific ends. To black men, women, and children who ran to the Union army, ‘citizenship’ was less the ultimate objective than it was a means to the particular goal of autonomy for themselves, their loved ones, and their communities.” (14)

PRIMARY SOURCES:

BALTIMORE CONNECTIONS:

  • N/A

bottom of page