Manning, Chandra
What This Cruel War Was Over: Soldiers, Slavery, and the Civil War
Vintage (New York)
2007
OUR SYNOPSIS: Chandra Manning illuminates “what individual soldiers thought about the relationship between slavery and the Civil War.” (4) She delves into the personal in the war’s archive, focusing on diaries, letters, and regimental newspapers written during the conflict to amplify individual stories. She argues the preservation of slavery to preserve their perceived interests motivated Confederate soldiers, while commitment to the United States and the values it represented motivated Union troops. Manning convincingly disproves all arguments that slavery was not central to the war cause on both sides. Confederates did not need to be enslavers themselves to fight for slavery since even non-enslaver southerners subscribed to the idea that slavery was foundational to the idea of property ownership. She shows this often directly relating to manhood and its connection to providing for one’s family. Union soldiers also saw the war as connected to their manhood and creating an ideal future for their families. The core unifying motivator for northerners was the preservation of liberty.
BIG QUESTIONS:
How did regular Civil War soldier experiences of the war differ from those of more senior officers or political decision-makers?
How did soldiers impact how the Civil War was fought and thus the future of the nation?
FEATURE QUOTES:
“If we listen to what soldiers had to say as they fought the Civil War, the men in the ranks do not allow us to duck the uncomfortable issue of human slavery, but rather take us right to the heart of it. They force us to look at it unflinchingly, and what is more, to see it as a national, not simply southern, issue that defined a war and shaped a nation.” (18)
“The words and actions of Green, Davidson, and Emerson show that to many of its participants, the Civil War was nothing less than a clash between competing ideals about how Americans should interpret and enact their founding ideals. The problem, as soldiers on both sides saw it, was that the opposing section posed a direct threat to everything that mattered.” (21)
PRIMARY SOURCES (AND ALSO A BALTIMORE CONNECTION IN THIS CASE):
Christian A. Fleetwood, "Diary of Christian A. Fleetwood for 1864," https://www.loc.gov/item/mss20784_01/.
BALTIMORE CONNECTIONS:
N/A